Who Answers To The People?

THE ILLINOIS GOP'S BIGGEST FAILURE ISN'T LOSING ELECTIONS. IT'S THE LEADERSHIP THAT NEVER ANSWERS FOR THEM.

November 15, 2026•23 min read

THEY KEEP THE POWER. REPUBLICANS KEEP LOSING. WHO REALLY RUNS THE ILLINOIS GOP?

Behind the closed doors of Illinois Republican politics lies a trail of money, powerful relationships, concentrated voting power and election defeats. After seven investigations, the evidence leads to a troubling question: Who is holding the people running the Illinois Republican Party accountable for its failures?

A PERSONAL MESSAGE TO OUR READERS

From the Editor's Desk

Before you begin reading the final installment of our seven-part investigation into the Illinois Republican Party, I want to take a moment to speak directly to you, our readers.

When our team began this investigation, we knew we would be asking some uncomfortable questions. We knew we would be examining people in positions of influence, following money, reviewing political relationships and looking closely at decisions that some would probably prefer remain out of the public spotlight.

What we did not know was just how much we would uncover along the way.

This series was never about attacking Republicans or helping Democrats. It was about something far more important. Accountability.

Illinois Republicans have been losing elections, losing political influence and, perhaps most troubling, losing the confidence of people who once believed in the party. That should concern everyone who believes Illinois deserves a competitive political system.

A healthy democracy needs strong political parties willing to challenge one another, offer voters meaningful choices and hold those in power accountable.

And that includes holding their own leadership accountable.

We believe the Illinois Republican Party has reached a critical point. Continuing down the same road, with the same problems and expecting different results, is not a plan for rebuilding. If the party hopes to survive as a meaningful political force in Illinois, something has to change.

That belief is what motivated this investigation.

Along the way, something else happened that I believe you deserve to know about.

Members of our team at FactsFirstus.com have received troubling threats connected to our reporting.

Let me be clear. These have not been threats against anyone's life. But they have been concerning enough that we are documenting them and taking them seriously.

We are not sharing this to seek sympathy or make ourselves part of the story. We are sharing it because readers deserve to understand some of the challenges that can come with investigating people and organizations that hold political influence.

It also helps explain something readers occasionally ask us.

Why don't we identify our individual investigative reporters?

There is a reason.

We have chosen to protect the identities of the reporters working on sensitive investigations. That provides an additional measure of personal security, particularly when reporting generates hostility. It can also help our journalists develop sources, ask difficult questions and pursue information without their individual identities becoming the focus.

We understand that anonymity carries responsibility. Protecting a reporter's identity should never mean avoiding accountability for what we publish.

Our editorial team stands behind our reporting. We are responsible for the accuracy of our stories, the evidence supporting them and correcting mistakes when they are identified.

We do not expect everyone to agree with our conclusions. In fact, we welcome thoughtful disagreement.

What we ask is that people examine the information, consider the records and participate in the conversation.

That is what independent journalism should encourage.

And despite the hostility our reporting has sometimes generated, our commitment has not changed.

We will continue asking questions. We will continue following public money. We will continue examining decisions made by elected officials and political organizations, regardless of party affiliation.

We will also continue giving attention to stories that deserve scrutiny, even when those stories are uncomfortable or unpopular.

Because journalism loses its purpose when reporters become more concerned about whom they might offend than what the public deserves to know.

Now we have reached the final installment of this investigation.

Over the previous six parts, we examined election losses, campaign spending, party leadership, political influence, the concentration of voting power and efforts to change how the Illinois Republican Party operates.

Each installment revealed another piece of a much larger picture.

Today, we bring those pieces together.

And what emerges is a story about more than one political party, one election or one individual.

It is a story about power, the people who exercise it and the responsibility that comes with it.

Before you begin, I want to thank those of you who have followed this series, shared our reporting, provided information and encouraged us to keep digging.

Your trust is something we take seriously.

And for those reading FactsFirstus.com for the first time, welcome. Our stories are free to read, and subscribing is free as well. We believe important information should be accessible to everyone, not just those willing or able to pay for it.

Our commitment to you is straightforward. We will pursue the facts, examine the evidence and report what we find. We will not promise that every story will confirm what you already believe.

We will promise to keep asking the questions that matter.

And now, after six installments examining what has happened to the Illinois Republican Party, we arrive at the question that has been waiting at the end of this investigation.

When a political party keeps losing, but the people making its most important decisions continue holding power, who is really in charge, and who is holding them accountable?

That is where Part Seven begins.

Thank you for reading, for thinking independently and for helping us keep the conversation going.

The Editor

FACTSFIRSTUS.COM

PART SEVEN | THE FINAL INVESTIGATION

By Staff Writer | November 15, 2026

The election was over, the votes had been counted, and Illinois Republicans were once again confronting a reality that had become painfully familiar. After months of fundraising, campaigning, knocking on doors and promising voters a different direction, the party had suffered another round of defeats. The statewide ticket had lost, Republicans had surrendered additional ground in the Illinois House, and the people who had worked so hard to elect them were left wondering what had happened.

But while candidates and supporters were still absorbing the results, another political contest was already taking shape behind the scenes in Springfield. This one would not involve television commercials, campaign signs or voters standing in line at their polling places. It would be decided by Republican lawmakers themselves, and the prize was control of their legislative leadership.

House Republican Leader Tony McCombie had scheduled a leadership election for November 17, just days after an election that left Republicans with fewer seats and more questions about their future. McCombie reportedly had commitments from 21 lawmakers, enough to retain her position if those commitments held.

Not everyone was comfortable moving ahead so quickly. Thirteen Republican lawmakers circulated a letter urging McCombie to postpone the leadership vote until members had an opportunity to examine the election results and discuss what needed to change. They were not necessarily demanding her removal. They wanted the caucus to confront its losses before deciding who should lead it through the next legislative session.

Their message went to the heart of a problem that has followed the Illinois Republican Party for years. The organization had just suffered another defeat, yet the process of retaining leadership was moving forward before lawmakers had completed an examination of the results.

Meanwhile, discussions about possible leadership changes were already underway. Representative Regan Deering of Decatur was exploring support for the top position, while McCombie was reportedly considering elevating Representative Brad Stephens of Rosemont to deputy leader. Representative Adam Niemerg warned that retaining McCombie could leave Republicans divided.

The dispute was revealing. Republican lawmakers were arguing over the future of their leadership at the very moment their party was struggling to explain another election failure. Some wanted an examination of the losses before choosing a leader. Others were already preparing to settle the leadership question.

For voters who had watched the party lose ground year after year, it was another example of an organization whose internal political arrangements appeared to be moving faster than its efforts to understand why it kept losing.

Behind the disagreement lay a much larger story involving campaign money, political relationships, concentrated voting power and a governing structure that ordinary Republican voters have limited direct influence over.

Over the previous six installments of this investigation, FactsFirstus.com examined the decisions, financial records and leadership arrangements that have shaped the Illinois Republican Party. The findings revealed an organization with no shortage of leaders, committees, consultants or political machinery. What has been much harder to identify is a consistent process for holding those leaders accountable when their decisions fail to produce results.

One place to see the consequences is Illinois' 97th House District.

In 2024, Republican Gabriella Shanahan came within approximately four percentage points of winning the district. For a party desperate to gain ground in the legislature, that was an opportunity worth building upon. Shanahan had demonstrated that Republicans could compete, and another election was only two years away.

Then circumstances changed. Democratic Representative Harry Benton resigned in July 2026 amid sexual harassment allegations, which he denied, and Jessica Dixon Heitman was appointed to replace him. Shanahan was running again, this time against a newly appointed incumbent in a district where she had recently come close to winning.

Republican leaders had reason to pay attention. McCombie identified the district as an opportunity, and campaign organizations invested resources in the contest.

But by the final weeks of the campaign, the financial imbalance was substantial. An analysis of October campaign disclosures identified approximately $1.41 million in in-kind assistance for Dixon Heitman, compared with approximately $541,000 for Shanahan. Republicans provided additional assistance late in the campaign, including more than $111,000 during the final week of October.

When the votes were counted, the result was devastating for Republicans. Dixon Heitman received 23,014 votes, or 61.1 percent, while Shanahan received 14,650 votes, or 38.9 percent.

A district Republicans had nearly won two years earlier had become a defeat of more than 22 percentage points.

That result should demand more than another promise to rebuild. It should prompt a detailed examination of how Republican campaign leaders evaluated the district, when they committed resources, how they responded to the Democratic investment and why a previously competitive race moved so dramatically against their candidate.

Those are management decisions. They involve strategy, organization, fundraising and the allocation of campaign resources. They are precisely the kinds of decisions political leaders are entrusted to make.

Yet the discussion following the election quickly returned to who would occupy the leadership positions, rather than a public accounting of the decisions that helped shape the results.

The political relationships behind those decisions deserve attention as well.

McCombie's longtime colleague and political ally Norine Hammond served as a deputy Republican leader. Hammond had nominated McCombie for Speaker of the Illinois House in 2023, and McCombie again selected her for a leadership role in 2025.

But Hammond's own political future changed dramatically when she faced Republican primary challenger Josh Higgins.

In January 2026, Higgins' campaign filed a lawsuit naming Hammond's campaign, the Illinois Republican Party, the House Republican Organization and several party officials. The complaint alleged that campaign mailings supporting Hammond benefited from discounted nonprofit postage rates and challenged financial arrangements involving Republican political organizations. The allegations were disputed.

The lawsuit brought into public view the financial and organizational relationships that can develop between party leadership, legislative campaign organizations and individual candidates. Higgins argued that those relationships had benefited the incumbent he was challenging.

In March, Republican primary voters delivered their verdict. Higgins defeated Hammond in a three-candidate contest, receiving approximately 58 percent of the vote to Hammond's 32 percent.

The voters had removed a longtime incumbent who held a position in Republican legislative leadership.

That outcome exposed an important distinction. Republican voters can remove legislative incumbents through primary elections. But removing the people who govern the state party itself is a different matter.

And that brings us to a comparison that may help explain why so many Republicans are questioning the direction of their party.

Imagine owning a business that has been losing customers for years. Sales are declining, competitors are taking away market share, and every time you ask management what went wrong, you're told about another plan to turn things around. The people running the business assure you that better days are coming, but when the next financial report arrives, the losses have grown.

Now imagine discovering that the people who own that business have no direct vote in choosing its board of directors. Instead, the board is selected through an internal process, and some directors have substantially more voting power than others. That board then chooses the person responsible for leading the organization.

You might begin to wonder whether the problem is simply the people managing the business or the system that allows them to remain in charge.

The comparison becomes particularly interesting when examining the Illinois Republican Party, because an official Republican precinct committeeperson manual describes the party's State Central Committee as its "Board of Directors."

That description identifies the governing body responsible for some of the party's most consequential decisions, including selecting the state chairman.

Bob Grogan holds that position today. He was selected by the State Central Committee, not through a direct statewide vote of Republican primary voters.

The committee has seventeen members, one associated with each congressional district. But those seventeen members do not possess equal voting strength.

Under the party's weighted voting system, a member's influence is tied to Republican primary participation in the district represented. The arrangement gives some committee members considerably more power than others.

Ahead of the May 2026 chairman election, published voting weights showed Zach Emberton with 16.5 percent, Rhonda Belford with 15.9 percent and Jim Rule with 10.2 percent. Together, those three members accounted for 42.6 percent of the reported voting power at that time.

Three people. Seventeen committee seats. Nearly 43 percent of the voting strength.

Those numbers reveal how much influence can be concentrated within a relatively small portion of the organization. A committee that selects the chairman and makes important party decisions operates under a system in which a handful of members can exercise extraordinary influence over the outcome.

And that raises a much larger accountability problem.

When Republicans lose elections, voters can remove individual candidates. But the governing committee responsible for selecting the party chairman and directing important organizational decisions is chosen through an indirect process involving precinct committeepersons and party conventions.

The people making those decisions are therefore insulated from the kind of direct statewide primary judgment that candidates for public office must face.

That distinction becomes especially significant when the committee is deciding how the party's financial resources will be used.

During the 2026 campaign, Aaron Del Mar, the Republican nominee for lieutenant governor and himself a member of the State Central Committee, sought approximately $150,000 in financial assistance for the statewide Republican ticket.

Del Mar and gubernatorial nominee Darren Bailey were confronting an enormous financial disadvantage against Governor JB Pritzker, who had committed tens of millions of dollars of his own money to his reelection campaign.

The request became a confrontation inside the State Central Committee. Some members objected to approving the money without a detailed spending plan. Del Mar acknowledged that the plan was incomplete but maintained that the party needed to commit resources to helping its statewide candidates compete.

The committee rejected the request by a reported weighted vote of approximately 65 percent to 35 percent.

The decision was made in executive session. A complete public roll-call record identifying how each member voted has not been established.

That secrecy is important. A political party can establish rules for making internal decisions, but when those decisions affect candidates, campaign resources and the direction of the organization, its members and supporters have a legitimate interest in knowing who made them.

Del Mar was not asking the committee to fund a personal business venture. He was seeking assistance for the Republican statewide ticket, the candidates representing the party before voters across Illinois.

The request was denied, and the identities of the committee members responsible for the individual votes were not publicly disclosed in a complete roll call.

For an organization that routinely asks Republican voters to donate money, volunteer their time and support its candidates, that lack of transparency deserves scrutiny.

The financial records make the issue even more significant.

Illinois Files, which compiles reported campaign finance transactions, identifies $1,131,150 in contributions from the Illinois Republican Party to 23 candidates during the 2026 election cycle. The compilation includes 82 reported contributions beginning in January 2025.

Among the recipients were Republican legislative candidates Erica Harriss, who received approximately $149,207; Seth Lewis, approximately $145,889; Darby Hills, approximately $104,737; and Craig Wilcox, approximately $103,670. Gabriella Shanahan received approximately $55,194.

For Darren Bailey's gubernatorial campaign, the compilation identifies a contribution of $33,684.30 dated September 30, 2026.

These records show how the state party distributed reported direct assistance across campaigns. They also reveal a leadership organization making substantial financial decisions while the statewide ticket struggled to compete against an extraordinarily well-funded Democratic governor.

Republican leaders had to decide where their resources would go. They had to determine which candidates would receive assistance, how much support they would receive and when that support would arrive.

Those choices were not made by the volunteers distributing campaign signs or the Republican voters who contributed their hard-earned money. They were made by the people entrusted with directing the organization.

The financial decisions deserve to be evaluated against the results. Which investments helped Republicans win? Which strategies failed? Which competitive districts slipped away? And how were those lessons incorporated into the next round of leadership decisions?

That examination is especially important because the party's governing committee also controls the selection of the person responsible for leading the state organization.

It is a remarkable concentration of responsibility. The committee helps determine the party's direction, exercises authority over important resources and selects its chairman. Yet after another election defeat, the organization remains locked in arguments over whether its leadership structure should change.

Those arguments are not new.

At the 2024 Republican State Convention, reform advocates sought to restore direct primary elections for State Central Committee members. Doug Ibendahl prepared a resolution intended to change the selection process, but the proposal did not succeed.

Ibendahl subsequently accused convention leadership of blocking a vote on the measure and identified then-chairman Don Tracy as an opponent of the proposed reform.

The dispute reflected a longstanding division between Republicans who defend the existing system and those who believe rank-and-file primary voters should directly select the people governing their party.

The indirect system survived.

Two years later, after another election defeat, the argument returned with renewed urgency.

On November 9, Del Mar publicly called for a Republican convention in March 2027 to examine the party's bylaws, leadership structure and governing procedures. He also proposed stronger candidate recruitment, permanent regional field operations and improvements in fundraising.

Kristina McCloy of Concerned Parents of Illinois joined the call for reform.

Del Mar's assessment was pointed. He argued that simply replacing one chairman while leaving the same organizational structure intact would accomplish little.

The statement captured a growing frustration inside Republican ranks. The party had been changing candidates, replacing chairmen and promising new strategies for years. Yet the losses continued, and the governing structure remained a recurring source of internal conflict.

The issue was no longer simply whether Bob Grogan should remain chairman or whether Tony McCombie should continue leading House Republicans. It was whether the people who hold authority within the organization were prepared to accept responsibility for the record produced under their leadership.

That record is difficult to defend.

Republicans lost every statewide race in 2026. They suffered additional legislative defeats, including races in districts they had hoped to contest. The party's already limited influence in Springfield declined further, while Democrats strengthened their supermajorities.

The election also exposed problems that campaign volunteers and candidates had been describing for years. Recruiting candidates remained difficult in some districts. Fundraising was uneven. Campaign infrastructure varied from one region to another. Volunteers complained about the difficulty of obtaining basic campaign materials, while candidates struggled to compete against better-funded opponents.

These were not new problems discovered on election night. They were recurring organizational weaknesses that Republican leaders had repeatedly promised to address.

Grogan's response after the election made the contrast between leadership language and election results even more striking.

In a November interview, the state chairman described the losses as a "controlled burn," acknowledging that the outcome had been less controlled than he would have preferred.

For Republicans who had just watched their candidates lose and their legislative representation shrink, the phrase was extraordinary.

A controlled burn is supposed to be deliberate. It is supposed to be managed. It is supposed to serve a purpose.

But the Illinois Republican Party had just suffered another election in which its candidates lost statewide, its legislative position deteriorated and its supporters were left demanding answers.

Calling that outcome a controlled burn does not explain the campaign decisions that produced it. It does not identify which strategies failed, which investments delivered results or who should be responsible for correcting the problems.

And that is the issue at the center of this investigation.

Illinois Republicans have experienced repeated losses under successive leaders. Chairmen have changed. Candidates have changed. Campaign consultants have been hired, committees have met and new fundraising efforts have been announced.

Yet the party's position has continued to deteriorate.

The familiar response has been another promise to rebuild.

But rebuilding is not simply a word to be repeated after an election. It requires a serious examination of the decisions that brought an organization to its present condition. It requires identifying failures, changing strategies and establishing measurable standards for improvement.

Above all, it requires leadership willing to be judged by results rather than by its ability to retain internal support.

That is why the disagreement over McCombie's November 17 leadership election is so revealing.

Thirteen Republican lawmakers wanted time to examine the losses before choosing who would lead them. McCombie reportedly believed she already had the votes to remain in charge.

The contrast illustrates a problem that reaches far beyond one legislative caucus.

Within the Illinois Republican Party, the ability to win an internal leadership contest has not translated into an ability to win enough elections before the public.

The distinction matters because political organizations ultimately exist to persuade voters, recruit candidates, compete in elections and advance their principles through public office.

Committee titles, leadership positions and internal voting strength have value only when they contribute to those objectives.

For years, Illinois Republicans have asked their supporters to believe that the next election would be different. They have appealed for donations, encouraged volunteers to work harder and urged voters to remain loyal to the party.

Those supporters have answered the call. They have spent evenings making telephone calls, weekends knocking on doors and hours distributing signs or helping candidates reach voters.

Some have contributed money they could scarcely afford to spare. Others have invested years of their lives in precinct organizations, county committees and local campaigns.

They did those things because they believed the Illinois Republican Party could become a stronger political force.

They have every reason to expect the people running that organization to explain what happened to those efforts.

After seven investigations, the answer to the question of who controls the Illinois Republican Party is clearer.

Authority is distributed among the State Central Committee, the state chairman, legislative leaders and the political organizations responsible for supporting candidates. Each has a role in shaping the party's strategy, allocating resources and determining who occupies important leadership positions.

That structure also creates opportunities for responsibility to become divided. Legislative leaders can point to statewide fundraising problems. State party officials can point to candidate performance or the decisions of legislative campaign organizations. Campaign committees can point to the enormous financial advantages enjoyed by Democrats.

Meanwhile, the election losses continue.

The public record reveals the people occupying these positions, the rules under which they operate and many of the financial decisions they make. It also reveals a party in which important internal decisions can be made without a complete public accounting of individual votes.

The central problem is not that Illinois Republicans lack leaders. It is that their leadership has repeatedly failed to produce the electoral results their supporters were promised.

That is a record of organizational failure, and responsibility for addressing it belongs to the people who hold authority.

They cannot continue asking volunteers to work harder without examining whether their own decisions are working. They cannot expect donors to keep writing checks without demonstrating that their money is being used effectively. They cannot promise reform while resisting meaningful examination of the rules that determine who controls the organization.

And they cannot expect Republican voters to accept another round of leadership announcements as proof that anything has changed.

The party's future will not be determined by how many votes a chairman can secure from the State Central Committee or how many lawmakers a legislative leader can persuade to support another term.

It will be determined by whether the organization can recruit competitive candidates, raise and spend money effectively, rebuild its presence in communities where it has lost ground and persuade voters that its candidates deserve their support.

Those are the results by which leadership should be judged.

The people holding power within the Illinois Republican Party have an opportunity to examine the record and change the direction of the organization. They can make their decisions more transparent, establish clearer standards of accountability and demonstrate that the lessons of repeated defeats have finally been learned.

Or they can continue with the same internal arrangements, the same familiar promises and the same expectation that voters will eventually give them another chance.

The decision belongs to the leaders.

The consequences belong to the party's candidates, volunteers, donors and voters.

And that returns us to the business that has been losing customers year after year.

At some point, the people invested in that business stop accepting another optimistic presentation from management. They want to see the books. They want to know who made the decisions, why those decisions failed and what will be done differently.

Most importantly, they want to know whether the people responsible for the losses should continue running the business.

Illinois Republicans have reached that point.

Winning a leadership vote is not the same as winning the confidence of the people you are supposed to lead.

The party's leaders can continue selecting chairmen, organizing committees, distributing campaign resources and protecting their positions within the organization.

But they cannot vote themselves back into relevance.

They cannot appoint themselves to electoral victory.

And they cannot demand the confidence of Republican voters while avoiding a serious reckoning with the results of their own leadership.

After seven investigations, one conclusion stands above the rest.

The Illinois Republican Party does not have a shortage of people in charge. It has a shortage of accountability for what happens while they are in charge.

Until that changes, the promises of rebuilding will remain exactly what they have been for years: promises.

Power can be protected behind closed doors. Trust cannot. It has to be earned.

This concludes our seven-part investigation into the Illinois Republican Party. Every installment is available to read free at FactsFirstus.com. We encourage readers to examine the records, discuss the findings and share the reporting. Subscriptions are free as well.

Sources

Official records and party documents

Independent reporting and campaign finance records

Back to Blog