Rewarding Failure?

ILLINOIS GOP LOST MORE SEATS. WHY SHOULD ITS LEADERS KEEP THEIRS?

November 16, 2026•10 min read

THEY LOST SEATS. WILL THEIR LEADERS LOSE ANYTHING?

Twelve years without a statewide victory. Fifty legislative contests without a Republican challenger. Now lawmakers must decide whether accountability reaches their own leaders, or whether loyalty earns another renewal.

By Staff Writer
November 16, 2026

Apparently, there is still an election Illinois Republican leaders can win: the one decided by their colleagues.

On Tuesday, after another midterm defeat, House Republican Leader Tony McCombie and Senate Republican Leader John Curran could receive another term in charge. The candidates who lost their seats have already faced the consequences. Whether their leaders face any now depends on the Republican lawmakers casting those ballots.

McCombie reportedly says she has enough support to remain leader. Curran faces a challenger described as a long shot. Their leadership elections are scheduled for November 17.

For Republican supporters who supplied the donations, knocked on doors and asked their neighbors to believe in another turnaround, that prospect deserves an explanation. Their party lost more ground. Some of its own lawmakers are publicly demanding new leadership. Yet the internal vote could leave the same people directing the next campaign and asking everyone else to try again.

The incumbents want another term. Their colleagues will decide whether to give it to them, and those colleagues will share responsibility for what follows.

The record they are judging is difficult to dress up.

Illinois Republicans last won statewide elections in 2014, twelve years ago. Their last occupants of statewide executive office, Governor Bruce Rauner and Lieutenant Governor Evelyn Sanguinetti, left in January 2019.

This year, Republicans offered no candidate against Democrats in fifty legislative contests: 41 in the House and nine in the Senate. Nearly one-third of the 157 seats on the ballot gave voters no Republican choice.

In those fifty contests, a voter could disagree with the Democrat on every major issue and still find no Republican candidate to support. Before anyone could argue about the message, the money or the national mood, the Republican alternative was missing from the ballot.

Quite a head start for the party Republicans keep promising to defeat.

McCombie and Curran inherited weakened caucuses when they took over after the 2022 election. They also accepted responsibility for improving their operations. Their colleagues must now decide what progress justifies another term.

Some have already reached a conclusion.

State Representatives Chris Miller and Adam Niemerg say they will vote for new House leadership. State Senator Andrew Chesney will oppose Curran’s reelection, while State Senator Chris Balkema is challenging Curran for the position.

Those public commitments matter because challenging leadership inside a caucus can carry consequences beyond an uncomfortable conversation.

In January 2025, the Illinois Freedom Caucus accused McCombie of withholding resources from members who had not supported her for leader. State Representatives Chris Miller, Adam Niemerg, Brad Halbrook, Blaine Wilhour and Martin McLaughlin were named in the dispute. Their complaints covered committee spokesperson positions, communications assistance, research, bill analysis and other staff services. McCombie defended allocating leadership resources according to caucus priorities.

These are tools lawmakers use to examine legislation, communicate decisions and serve constituents. A member who challenges the leader must still show up the next morning, answer constituents and scrutinize the next bill. The work continues inside the organization whose leadership that member has opposed.

By February, reporting said privileges had been restored, including committee spokesperson assignments for Miller and Niemerg. But the confrontation had exposed the reach of leadership authority and the stakes of withholding support.

Now Miller and Niemerg are taking that stand again. They know how contentious the fight can become, and they have put their names behind another challenge.

“If we want to win in Illinois, we can’t keep running the same playbook. I’m voting for new leadership because House Republicans need fresh ideas and the backbone to put them to work.”

State Representative Chris Miller

Niemerg tied his decision directly to the election and the next campaign.

“House Republicans lost SIX seats in this election. We must UNIFY the party and push forward to 2028! It is for this reason, and many others, I will be voting for new leadership this Tuesday.”

State Representative Adam Niemerg

Their argument strips away the assumption that unity means another term for the incumbent. They are asking colleagues to unite around a different direction.

Other relationships point toward a more comfortable outcome for the leadership.

Before Election Day, State Representative Brad Stephens publicly pledged to stand beside McCombie.

“If McCombie goes down in flames, I’ll be on fire right by her side.”

State Representative Brad Stephens

After the election, McCombie was reported to be planning to elevate Stephens to deputy Republican leader, replacing outgoing State Representative Norine Hammond. The same reporting said McCombie had told colleagues she had secured 21 votes for another term.

The party lost ground. A loyal colleague could move up. The leader could stay.

Stephens’ pledge and reported advancement capture the question behind the “good ole boys” criticism: what carries more weight inside the organization, standing beside the leader or delivering results for the voters? McCombie’s supporters will cast their answer Tuesday. They should be prepared to explain it afterward.

Some House members wanted time for that discussion before casting their ballots. Thirteen Republicans reportedly circulated a letter seeking to delay the leadership election so the caucus could analyze its losses and discuss its direction. The demand was clear: examine the defeat before renewing the leadership.

Some members seeking a delay remained open to retaining McCombie if she offered a convincing plan. State Representative Regan Deering had been contacting colleagues about the position. The opposition was developing while the incumbent reportedly believed she had the votes to withstand it.

The warning signs had arrived before the returns. By October 23, concerns about McCombie’s future were being reported as Republicans contemplated substantial losses. McCombie denied soliciting leadership commitments and said she was seeking financial help for candidates being outspent.

Earlier in the cycle, she had promoted the new House Republican Organization board as equipped to strengthen recruitment, party building and electoral performance. Members now have those expectations and the election outcome before them.

For readers of FactsFirstus.com’s seven-part Illinois GOP investigation, Tuesday brings the series’ accountability question to a decision. Our reporting examined spending priorities, concentrated authority and the distance between grassroots Republicans and the people making decisions. The lawmakers voting for leadership now possess the authority to change course.

In the Senate, Chesney says he warned colleagues in March and again in May about the caucus’s direction and election readiness. His November 16 release acknowledged that Curran had always treated him as a gentleman, then delivered a far harsher judgment of his leadership.

“If Senate President Don Harmon could pick our leader for us, he would pick John Curran. And to be fair, I think most of the Democratic caucus would too. And that is not because we fight them too much. It’s because we don’t fight them at all.”

State Senator Andrew Chesney

A Republican senator is arguing that Democrats would welcome another term for his own leader. That accusation reaches the heart of the frustration: supporters want an opposition capable of challenging the people running Illinois.

Chesney wants a leader who gives the job full attention and presents a plan voters and precinct committeemen can understand and help execute. Balkema has offered to direct that effort, announcing his challenge November 13 and calling for an aggressive, unified campaign to regain seats. He also pointed to the coming legislative redistricting battle, when Republican strength will matter again.

“A defensive strategy is not a winning strategy.”

State Senator Chris Balkema

The reported arithmetic still favors Curran. Balkema was described as a long shot with an estimated three or four supporters. Curran declined to comment before the caucus election.

Here the public demands meet the internal vote count. A challenge can be forceful, the criticism unmistakable, and the incumbent can still retain enough colleagues to continue.

McCombie has offered her explanation for the defeat. In November 16 reporting, she pointed to national political conditions and the Republican label, questioning whether millions more in campaign funding would have changed the outcome.

Her colleagues can weigh that explanation against the decisions made in Illinois. Recruitment, fundraising, preparation and campaign support remain responsibilities leaders accept when they seek the job. Those decisions deserve examination before another campaign begins.

Outside the legislature, former Republican attorney general nominee Thomas DeVore has threatened to make members’ leadership choices an issue in their own primaries. He demanded the replacement of McCombie and Curran and warned of district-level text campaigns identifying their supporters.

“I am going to find out how every one of you voted.”

Thomas DeVore, former Republican nominee for Illinois attorney general

Illinois Review editor-in-chief Mark Vargas also publicly called for McCombie’s removal. McCombie accused both men of damaging Republicans and seeking attention.

DeVore’s warning would carry an internal decision back into lawmakers’ districts, where members could be asked what earned their support and what results they expected in return.

Across the aisle, Democrats have supplied an uncomfortable comparison. They gained seats, yet 26 incumbent and incoming House Democrats opposed another term for Speaker Chris Welch, citing management concerns and his handling of harassment allegations. Welch announced November 5 that he would not seek reelection as speaker.

Democrats expanded their power and demanded new leadership. Republicans lost ground and may renew theirs.

The wider Republican reform effort will continue beyond Tuesday. Aaron Del Mar has proposed a convention, revised bylaws, stronger recruitment and greater voter participation in party leadership. State party Chairman Bob Grogan has said the party will not intervene in the legislative caucus elections.

This decision belongs to the lawmakers. Chesney has stated what he believes the record requires.

“We cannot unite around failure. It’s time for a change.”

State Senator Andrew Chesney

After Tuesday, Republican lawmakers will return to their districts. Before long, they will again ask people to contribute, volunteer and believe that another campaign can end differently.

Those supporters deserve to know what their representative required before giving the leadership another chance. What changed? What commitment was secured? What result would finally make another renewal unacceptable?

Miller and Niemerg have made their choices public. Chesney has put his objections in writing. Balkema has offered to lead. Their colleagues must now decide whether to join them or stand behind the incumbents.

The candidates have already answered to the voters. Tuesday will show what their colleagues require of the leaders.

And when lawmakers return home asking Republicans to help change Springfield, voters should remember what they chose when the power to change it was in their hands.


Primary sources:

Additional sources:

Back to Blog