Illinois' Unraveling: Pritzker’s Fox News Defenses Crumble Amid Crime Lies, Federal Clashes, and a State’s Desperate Bid for Escape

As disputed safety claims collide with grim realities, sanctuary defiance invites DOJ threats, and downstate counties plot secession, Illinois confronts a cascade of failures under Gov. JB Pritzker’s leadership
By Staff Writer
October 24, 2025

The Moment Illinois’ Troubles Went National

CHICAGO – Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker’s rare appearance on Fox News’ Special Report Thursday evening was supposed to be a moment of triumph — a chance to defend his progressive record on the national stage. Instead, it exposed the unraveling threads of a state mired in crisis.

From his uneasy denial of Chicago’s homicide epidemic to escalating feuds with federal agents over sanctuary defiance — and now, whispers of counties preparing to flee to Indiana — Pritzker’s appearance turned into a portrait of a governorship besieged by denial and dysfunction.

Behind his practiced optimism lies a harsher reality: soaring taxes, unrelenting crime, a hollowed-out economy, and a state fraying along its own borders. After two terms of promises and one more in the making, the governor’s legacy looks less like progress — and more like a cautionary tale of leadership adrift.

Crime Denials Exposed: The Governor’s Uneasy Dance with Reality

The clash began almost instantly. Anchor Bret Baier asked the question that cuts deepest:
“Why does Chicago have the highest murder rate of all the big cities?”

Baier’s numbers were unflinching — FBI Uniform Crime Reporting data showed a 2024 homicide rate of 17.47 per 100,000 residents, the highest among the 50 largest U.S. cities, even surpassing Philadelphia, Houston, and New York.

Pritzker fired back:

“We’re not in the top 30. Our murder rate has been cut in half over the last four years, and every year it has gone down by double digits.”

But Baier pressed harder. “Chicago is number one,” he said, citing 591 murders in 2024 — the most of any city in America.

The tension was visible. Pritzker insisted the numbers were misleading. Yet, the facts are immovable: while shootings and carjackings dipped modestly in early 2025 — down 36% and 50% respectively — Chicago remains the nation’s undisputed murder capital. Illinois leads the country in total homicides, driven by Chicago’s relentless toll of bloodshed, with 331 murders already recorded by early October 2025.

Aggravated assaults and robberies sit 15% above national averages, and a state audit links a 20% recidivism surge to Pritzker’s own bail reforms.

Online, the moment exploded. Elon Musk called Pritzker’s statement a “flat-out lie,” while Illinois residents vented fury: a governor clinging to talking points as the state buries its dead. A lingering “data glitch” halting recidivism tracking since 2022 — a “blind spot” in the system — only deepens mistrust.

After spending over $500 million on violence prevention since 2019, the results remain devastatingly thin. Over 90,000 Illinoisans flee the state each year, many citing crime as the final straw.

This is not reform. It is the normalization of crisis — and under Pritzker, the crown of “America’s murder capital” still fits Chicago too well.

Sanctuary Escalation: Defiance, Danger, and a Clash with Federal Law

Baier turned to immigration, opening another wound.

“Do you believe any illegal immigrant charged with or convicted of a felony should be deported?” he asked.

“I think they ought to take the violent criminals and get them out of my state and get them out of the country,” Pritzker said, projecting cooperation. But when Baier pressed on sanctuary restrictions, Pritzker doubled down:

“No, we do [help].”

That claim collapses under scrutiny. Illinois’ TRUST Act and Way Forward Act explicitly block local police from aiding ICE, shielding thousands from deportation.

Just this week, Pritzker escalated the standoff. On October 22, Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias announced a public hotline urging residents to report federal agents allegedly tampering with vehicle plates during raids — calling it “illegal, unsafe.”

The very next day, Pritzker signed Executive Order 2025-12, creating the Illinois Accountability Commission to investigate ICE for “harassment” during operations like Midway Blitz — a sweep that federal data shows netted 1,200 criminals, 85% of them felons linked to gangs and assaults.

Pritzker accused agents of “grabbing U.S. citizens,” but DHS reports reveal a different picture — one of targeted enforcement against violent offenders.

Worse still, his policies may have deadly consequences. Federal agents conceal license plates not to deceive — but to survive. DHS intelligence shows Mexican cartels offering bounties on ICE and CBP officers: $2,000 for doxxing, $50,000 for assassination. Chicago-based cartel cells monitor agent movements, making anonymity a matter of life and death.

By exposing these tactics through his hotline and commission, Pritzker is accused of endangering federal officers — in a state already draining $250 million a year on migrant care with no safety gains to show for it.

This isn’t resistance. It’s reckless governance masquerading as moral courage.

Federal Backlash: The DOJ Lowers the Boom

The response from Washington was swift — and ominous.

On October 23, Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche sent letters to sanctuary states, Illinois included, demanding an end to interference “or face prosecution.”

Attorney General Pam Bondi raised the stakes even higher:

“If they think I won’t [charge you], they have not met me.”

The warning lands atop a February DOJ lawsuit already targeting Pritzker, Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson, and Cook County for violating the Supremacy Clause. It accuses Illinois of harboring felons and obstructing federal law.

Meanwhile, court battles over National Guard deployments, migrant spending audits, and hiring probes mount, all as Illinois ranks dead last in economic equity and 48th in growth, shrinking 2.2% in early 2025.

Pritzker brushed off the DOJ’s threat as “garbage.” But beneath the bravado, the peril is real — a potential showdown that could see state officials facing federal prosecution.

A governor once seen as an ambitious reformer now faces the federal government’s wrath — a lonely figure fighting battles he created.

Downstate Revolt: Secession Talk Turns from Symbolic to Serious

If Pritzker’s struggles in Washington weren’t enough, his troubles at home are multiplying.

On October 22, Indiana’s Boundary Adjustment Commission met — notably without Illinois participation, even though Pritzker is empowered to appoint five members. The commission, chaired by Speaker Todd Huston, is exploring whether up to 74 Illinois counties — representing 2.8 million residents — could legally join Indiana.

The message from testifiers was raw and desperate: “We’re treated like a drain,” said Eric Ivers. Another, Scott Carpenter, blamed “bad Illinois law” for suffocating rural life. Organizer G.H. Merritt admitted the secession bill is “a message to Springfield.”

“Since 2020, 33 Illinois counties have passed ‘advisory referenda’ to secede.”
— Testimony from the October 22 hearing

Their grievances are as old as they are sharp: $250 billion in pension debt, heavy-handed gun laws, and urban-focused policies that ignore downstate needs.

With seven more counties joining the movement in 2024 and Pritzker leaving commission seats vacant, Illinois’ fractures now stretch beyond politics — they reach the map itself.

Rural Illinois is no longer whispering about secession. It’s organizing for it.

The Breaking Point: A Governor at Odds with His People

From Chicago’s crime-ravaged neighborhoods to small-town boardrooms along the Indiana border, a sense of exhaustion hangs over Illinois.

Pritzker’s tenure — marked by 43% spending growth since 2019, 49 tax hikes adding $6.7 billion in burdens, and public schools ranking near the bottom nationally — has left residents furious.

An August 2025 Illinois Policy Institute poll found his favorability underwater, with 60% of voters blaming him for high taxes and an exodus that saw 235,000 residents flee from 2020–2024.

Democrats lament pension failures. Independents decry stagnant job recovery — the slowest in the Midwest. Republicans rage over sanctuary spending. The disillusionment cuts across lines once thought immovable.

As one voter wrote online, “Pritzker’s Illinois isn’t home anymore — it’s a warning label.”

And yet, even as lawsuits multiply and secession looms, Pritzker insists:

“Illinois follows the law.”

But as National Guard troops mobilize, DOJ warnings escalate, and counties look eastward for escape, Illinois seems less a state under leadership — and more a state pleading for rescue.

Sources

• Fox News Special Report transcripts and clips (foxnews.com, October 23–24, 2025).

• FBI Uniform Crime Reporting data via World Population Review, AH Datalytics, and Council on Criminal Justice (2025).

• DHS and ICE operational briefings, including bounty intelligence (September–October 2025).

• Illinois Secretary of State and Chicago Sun-Times coverage of hotline and plate concealment (October 22, 2025).

• DOJ lawsuit filings and warnings (February–October 2025).

• Indiana Capital Chronicle, Chicago Tribune, WTHR (October 22–23, 2025).

• Illinois Policy Institute poll and economic reports (August 2025).

• X reactions and state audit data (2024–2025).

#PritzkerCrimeCoverUp #IllinoisMurderCapital #SanctuaryShowdown #PritzkerVsDOJ #IllinoisSecessionMovement #IllinoisExodusCrisis